Resource Legislation Amendment Bill – Committee Stage (15) – Part 1

Resource Legislation Amendment Bill – Committee Stage (15) – Part 1

Articles, Blog , , 0 Comments


have provided the solutions to this Parliament to vote on we’ve shown through our detailed technical studies that a major emissions reductions are possible but it’s not going to happen if companies like Nova get away with getting consents a massive polluting power stations and climate change just can’t even be considered so my challenge to parties are if you’re series of that climate change make sure you support this amendment so our major environmental law can actually finally consider climate change I call peony Hilary car by mr. chairman thank you for this opportunity I rise to take a fall on the resource legislation amendment bill so i would rather not debate the merits of whether or not you should have all the multi-party should have navigated the you amaldi down this particular pathway i want to focus particularly on some of the information and detail and the forces of the bill sir namely and close 3858 mb2 where it talks about the coordination of the resources required to make sure that negotiations and any kind of meeting after a notice of intention to to work with local authorities I wonder sir exactly what does that mean for the likes of napoli the biggest tribe or marta hid me the biggest kapoor with the net tribe who actually don’t have the resources to front up to those kinds of meetings they haven’t been able to settle their treaty settlements and I want to say this to the house there’s a reason why this government despite their hard-working they’re hard forced efforts and settling treaty claims have been unable to settle up napoli to have been unable to sit over the Napoli what they’re suggesting with this type of bill sir is that one we authority or one huh boo or or any collection what they are I can come together and work with the local authority with issues regarding to resource management they are remain so let me put it to you like this there are 55 hapu in Napoli 55 huh boo are we suggesting sir that under this particular clause 3858 mb to the coordination of resources required for either one of those huh boo a collection of those hapu or Annie we like Napoli will be able to come to the table with the local authority on an equal footing knowing full well that the local authority might be able to speak for a small districts such as I don’t know found out a couple he are able to claim mount Malaya which falls in the final a catchment the local body authority they claim Minaya as one of the pillars of the house of Napoli so that means that the organization based out of Cocoa here will then be down in finally working with the final a council suit and hapu within that particular catchment there are numerous there’s at least a dozen I see one of them Sir made a submission on this particular bill patouhot aqui key part to hotoke care are live around the Green Bay or the Marsden point area in farhadi so they made a number of I thought good recommendations and their submission where they thought that this particular bill could work for them sir I noticed as I read their submission and and the recommendations that they made I noticed that they aren’t in this bill in fact quite a different pathway was was pursued compared to the kind of solid and robust submission that pot ahora Kiki made on this particular bill su and I’m concerned when I consider within my electorate of Tamaki Makaurau sue there are big issues made around a wii and hapu and I wonder after years of fighting for an urban voice or urban recognition within any of the types of settlements or future aspirations of TB Maori the Maori people I wonder where the urban voice is and I wonder to sue where that might fit in a very complex web that exists in Tamaki makoto so you’ve got nominal fee Noah settlement build it acknowledges the tribes within Tamaki Makoto some of those tribes have already settled on their own to cover though are mocking RT file to a cure darkie and others what about the third-biggest tribe in this country urban Maori those who don’t actually affiliate to either not see fire to a cured RK they don’t affiliate touka widow our monkey and tar monkey Makoto of those tribes to cover though our monkey Marty file to a cured RK is it their responsibility to engage with all of the MALDI that live there I don’t think that’s their responsibility I think that’s quite an unfair expectation but I also equally think that it’s important that open Maori have a particular voice have a particular say within this piece of legislation to so that raises concerns how are they expected to come together on the table to the table on an equal footing on such an important issue sir Sir penny you know thank you sir I want to continue sir on cross 3858 in 4b and it’s this particular part which i think some supplements or supports anyway my notion around well who’s going to be in and who’s going to be out who’s in and who’s out and it stretches it in particular will find that situation and Tamaki makoto so I’ve already spoken about those who have settled under Nahrmahn rafinha I’ve already spoken about those who have currently already settled their bills now Jafar tokyo doki to cover de la marque what about those who haven’t yet settled their particular bills their treaty settlements ooh where’s the scope for them after if by miracle the organizations or the OEM happy with and Tom marquee Makoto are able to rally together to be able to oh she ate and work with the local authority on an equal footing where are those people expected to come and I see that it does say that they’re able to add to the conversation or add to the particular negotiation sometime later but I wonder sir will they agree with those things that have already been organized and agreed to between the parties ewee hubbu and the local authority so it’s all of these types of issues that we think haven’t actually been thought through clearly enough and I think it’s rich for members on the other side of the house to say that ewee Maori or Maori leaders support this pathway that’s being pursued by the Maori Party and the National Party read the night so far too icky or arcane settlement read the tribal setup I read the submission so I read the submissions they all say there are some serious concerns in fact something make recommendations that aren’t even considered in this bill yet already expressed concerns about the kind of pathway that we’re heading down with with the proposed changes supported by the Maori Party and its be clear and the Maori Party are saying that the tribal leaders have all supported this I already named Napoli the largest drive in the country I don’t see any of them up will he submissions being made I don’t see Ed of an apple he deal being chased in this particular bill sir urban Maori just to reiterate my points here those are of great concern to me those moldy who live in Tamaki makoto might not necessarily have a direct say over the resources that are shared and Tamaki makoto but what if they want to build on their house extend on the house they’ve got to apply through this particular process with the IRA mate I wonder serve urban Maori can click the vice as an authority to be able to vouch for to be able to advocate for issues regarding two simple things like house renovations for themselves I’m not too sure those types of issues to our questions I’ll leave with the minister and his advisers and in the hope that we can get some sort of clarification because I recall the words of my colleague here Mariama fox with regard to stepping backwards in time towards colonization and leaving Marty out of the conversation well times have changed since the 1840 signing of the Treaty of Waitangi so and there are a lot of Maori I’d argue in Tamaki Makoto who are being left out with the proposals being made in this particular amendment bill sir so I finish with my contribution by asking the Minister for some clarity around those complex webs that have already been set up with treaty settlements I named Napoli who haven’t settled yet but have well over 55 hapu within that particular large tribe and whether or not that will cause some complexities some issues into the future sir and i look forward to hearing from the minister on the meta felt hyphen

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *